Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?



Tribunal appointments: Central government defers from SC

Invoking “breach of judicial independence”, the Centre warned the Supreme Court on Thursday against putting down the policy choice fixing eligibility, selection course, and tenure for tribunal chairpersons and members, which has been enacted as the Tribunal Reforms Act.

The news: The Centre said it was distressing that the apex court feels that “judicial independence” could be jeopardised if Parliament accepted the federal government’s policy choice to reduce tribunal chairpersons and members’ tenure to four years from the SC-urged five years.

  • The Centre informed that “by applying one’s mind to either the provisions relating to tenure of four years, or minimum age of 50 years, or to the panel of two names to be recommended, or for the government to take a decision on the recommendations ‘preferably’ within three months, one is confused if one were told that all this relates to independence of the judiciary.”
  • “It would be mere semantics if, in fact, it has no relationship to independence of the members or the chairperson of the tribunals. Independence would be affected, only if the tenure; or terms and conditions, are such that the executive is able to control the will of the member or the chairperson of the tribunal. With judicial dominance in the search-cum-selection committee (SCSC) which recommends the continuance or re-appointment of members, whether for four years or five years, these fears are unfounded,” the Centre mentioned.
  • Neither the executive nor the legislature can be stripped of their ability to make policy-making laws, because judicial pronouncements would otherwise violate the constitutional requirement of separation of powers.
  • This is why Parliament has no choice but to assert its constitutional right to govern under the rule of law, because otherwise the line between governance and judicial adjudication or decision-making would be obliterated.
  • This is the perplexing situation in which Parliament would be forced to relinquish its constitutional right to make laws for the country by deciding on policy based on the will of the 534 elected representatives of the people, which actually reflects the people’s will.
  • The authorities questioned the SC’s judgement in sticking to 10-year experience eligibility standards for advocates seeking appointment as tribunal members, and explained why these standards would not apply to other technical consultants seeking appointment as members. It also inquired as to whether the SC collegium had ever appointed an advocate with ten years of experience as an HC choose.
  • “Setting a minimum age for appointment of 50 years for all members, including advocates and chairpersons, would be applicable across the board.”
  • “This 50-year requirement ran counter to the direction that advocates only need 10 years of experience to be eligible for appointment to the Supreme Court, as the Constitution allows advocates with 10 years of experience to be appointed as high court judges. In the last 75 years, there has never been a single appointment of an advocate with 10 years of experience to an HC,” it stated.
  • “These are the areas where both Parliament and the executive stand perplexed as well settled principles are not being followed since it is only if the policy decision taken by the Parliament violates any fundamental right or any provision of law, would the court set aside such decision,” the Centre said.
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.




New Delhi, Sept 29- According to data updated on Thursday by the Union Health Ministry, 4,272 new instances of infections have been registered throughout...


J&K, Sept 29 – Two people were injured in two bombs that occurred within eight hours in the Udhampur district of Jammu and Kashmir...


Karnataka, Sept 28 – The Narcotics Wing of the Central Crime Branch (CCB) broke an inter-state narcotics conspiracy on Tuesday, arresting five people-four women...


New Delhi, Sept 28- India observed a modest increase in the number of Covid-19 cases in the country, reporting 3,615 instances on Wednesday. The...


New Delhi, Sept 28- Considering the decline in the number of theaters in India and to prevent its complete closure, the Ministry of Information...


New Delhi, Sept 28– The Popular Front of India (PFI) and any of its affiliates, allies, or fronts have been declared illegal associations by...

You May Also Like


The structure will be built for a Public Health Centre (PHC), which will be the sole government health facility near the crash site. The...


It appears that Twitter is full of like-minded people who have had similar ideas regarding marriage, particularly arranged marriage. And they’ve developed a hilarious...


Microsoft Corp. Chief Executive Officer Satya Nadella’s son Zain Nadella, died Monday morning.  The news: Zain was 26 years old and had been born...


According to a tweet from the UK Ministry of Defence, the Russian Ministry of Defense confirmed the use of its TOS-1A weapon system in...